Caretaker vs Caregiver: Which One Do You Need for Home Care?

Pexels Kampus Production 7551607

While a caretaker and caregiver are both care providers, it is crucial to realize that these two terms have significant differences.

A caregiver’s roles are specific to caring for patients with illnesses, children, or the elderly. On the other hand, the job of a caretaker is broader, depending on the needs of their employer. They can provide emotional or physical care and support or be hired to look after a house or property.

Let’s understand more about the similarities, differences, and job scopes of a caretaker and caregiver. Aside from providing care, what are the other responsibilities of a caretaker and caregiver? And let’s also dive into the alternatives for caretaker caregiver roles.

Caretaker vs Caregiver – Difference and Job Responsibilities

Even though both caretakers and caregivers share the same objective of providing support for older adults, children, and other care recipients with special needs, it is crucial to recognize the difference between the two words.

While family members or relatives often perform caregiving without payment, caretaking is a job that requires payment. This means that you specifically hired someone for the role of a caretaker to look after a family member, animals, goods, or properties.

On the other hand, a caregiver can be a hired professional trained to provide support and medical assistance to the elderly or children. But they can also be other family members who volunteered for the task and did it for free.

Despite the significant difference, a caretaker and caregiver must be motivated by their passion for helping to do their tasks properly. They both have to accept the reality of their roles while maintaining their boundaries and sustaining self-care and their own needs to avoid burnout.

Caregiving and caretaking provide care and support and are motivated by love, respect, and care resulting from acceptance and trust.

Understanding the difference between caretakers and caregivers is essential to ensuring that healthy techniques and boundaries are set with a care recipient. Thus, it will help prevent communication breakdowns, misunderstandings, and circumstances that could endanger the mental health of the care recipient and the carer. Giving care can be a lonely job, so whether they’re employed or not, all those around them must ensure they maintain well-defined boundaries.

Even when things get challenging, it’s critical to emphasize the privacy of a person’s life and well-being. It’s not selfish for a carer to stand back, relax, and put some space between yourself and the person you’re caring for. You can avoid burnout and preserve a healthy relationship with the care recipient and other family members involved by having sufficient personal and emotional support and keeping a healthy social life outside your job.

Caretaker – The Characteristics and Responsibilities of Caretakers

A caregiver can unintentionally become a caretaker, and vice versa. This can result in frustration and an unhealthy co-dependent relationship. This is why the main difference between caretaking and caregiving must be settled from the start, and the boundaries of the job must also be laid out to avoid co-dependency.

If the caretaker begins taking control, it can lead to the job becoming counterproductive. If not helped, it can cause harm to both the caregiver and the care recipient rather than achieving the intended purpose.

First and foremost, a caretaker accepts the job because they need the money. They are usually driven by their own needs and not by empathy for a child or elderly care recipient. However, they may develop such closeness as they last in the job.

Caretakers – The Characteristics

It’s not easy being a caretaker; taking care of others, whether people or property, requires healthy stamina and mind. Caretakers must understand their responsibility to the job since they are employed but must also ensure they take care of themselves.

Here are the important characteristics you must have to become a professional and responsible caretaker. You must have these traits whether you’re a carer of a child, an elderly, or a property:


A caretaker must be patient, especially when working with an elderly or child with cognitive or physical impairments.


Caretakers must have a deep sense of compassion for the individuals they are taking care of. They should be able to provide emotional support to the person they are looking after when needed.


Caretakers must be flexible and adaptable to changing situations. They should be able to adjust their caregiving approach based on the individual’s needs and preferences.

Organizational skills

Caretakers must be organized and able to manage their time effectively. This is especially true for caretakers assigned with more roles than taking care of the elderly. They need to fit all their tasks into their schedule to avoid doing an unhealthy caretaking performance.

Good communication skills

Caretakers must have good communication skills to effectively communicate with their care recipients, family member, or other people they may be required to speak with.

Caretaker – The Responsibilities

The responsibilities of a caretaker often are almost the same as the roles of a caregiver. However, there is a connotation that a caretaker does not do their job out of compassion.

It may even come to a point that a caretaker becomes too controlling that the person they are caring for loses self-confidence until they become a dependent adult to their caretaker. It’s also usual to hear of a caretaker being oblivious to others’ opinions. They feel like they know everything, leading them to decide for their patients based on their own choices while bypassing a family member and other loved ones.

It doesn’t have to be this way; you can always rise above the rest as a caretaker. You must ask for boundaries but also know the limitations of what you can and can’t get involved in. You have to be professional all the time and be responsible for all your actions and decisions.

Here are the responsibilities you can be tasked with as a caretaker:

Housekeeping tasks

A caretaker can be responsible for helping with housekeeping tasks such as cleaning, laundry, and grocery shopping. This ensures the living environment is clean and safe for the individual they are caring for.

Assistance with Activities of Daily Living

One of the main responsibilities of a caretaker is to assist with activities of daily living. This may include helping with bathing, dressing, grooming, and toileting.


Caretakers should provide companionship to their clients to reduce feelings of loneliness or isolation. This may include engaging in activities such as playing games, going for walks, or simply talking.

Medication management

A caretaker may also be responsible for managing their clients’ medications. This includes administering the medication on time, tracking dosage, and ensuring that prescriptions are refilled when needed.

Mobility assistance

Caretakers may assist with mobility by helping their clients get in and out of bed, move around the house, and get in and out of vehicles.

Coordination of care

A caretaker can also be tasked to coordinate care with other healthcare providers, such as doctors or nurses. This ensures that the individual’s medical needs are being met and receiving appropriate care.

Reporting changes in health

Caretakers should monitor their clients’ health and report the difference to healthcare providers or family members. This includes monitoring a person physically and noting changes in their mental health, medication needs, and overall well-being.

Caregiver – The Characteristics and Responsibilities of Caregivers

A caregiver can be a family member who volunteers to provide care. They can also be a professional employed to support patients unable to perform daily activities independently due to various physical, cognitive, or medical conditions. Caregivers can be employed at homes to look after a person or work professionally, such as in nursing homes or hospitals.

Caregiver – The Characteristics

A caregiver takes care of a patient full-time or on a visiting basis. A caregiver refers to a person trained to render the support a patient requires or provide medical assistance if needed.

Here are the traits most professional caregivers and family caregivers possess. Ensure that you are equipped with the following before taking the role of a live in caregiver Singapore:


A caregiver must have a deep sense of empathy and understanding towards those they care for. It must be instilled in them, and they must always aim to be a good caregiver.


Caregiving can be a challenging and demanding job, and a caregiver must be patient and understanding with their patients regardless of how difficult or moody they are.


Caregivers must be adaptable and willing to adjust their routines and schedules to accommodate the needs of those they care for. Aside from ensuring the healthy life of their patient, a caregiver must also be ready to be asked to do other roles, like buying medicines or grocery shopping.


Dependability is critical for caregivers, as those they care for rely on them for their safety, comfort, and well-being.

Strong communication skills

Effective communication is essential for caregivers to understand the needs and concerns of their patients and their families.

Caregiver – The Responsibilities

A caretaker takes care of a patient or person needing assistance. This job is crucial since a person’s life lies in your hands, so you must be aware of their needs and required support.

Here are the main responsibilities of a good caregiver:

  • Basic care, such as grooming, feeding, bathing, and dressing
  • Administering medication and monitoring health conditions
  • Preparing meals and assisting with feeding
  • Providing emotional support and companionship
  • Ensuring their patient’s comfort and safe environment
  • Managing finances and coordinating care with medical professionals and family members

The Alternatives for a Caregiver and Caretaker

While home nursing care Singapore is becoming in demand through the years, not everyone is comfortable with the idea of having a stranger come into their home to provide care or support. Fortunately, other options are available for those who need assistance and support with daily tasks or medical care.

If you want to find support for a family member needing assistance without having to hire someone full-time and live in your own home, your best option is to find alternatives that can perform the roles.

In this case, these are the two alternatives for a caretaker and caregiver you can choose from:

Home Nurses

Home nurses are licensed medical professionals who provide medical care to patients in their homes. They may also assist with their patient’s daily activities, such as moving, eating, or bathing.

One advantage of hiring a home nurse is that they have medical training and can provide specialized care to patients with complex medical needs. They can work closely with the patient’s doctor to ensure they receive the appropriate care and treatment.

Another advantage of hiring a home nurse is that they can provide care on a flexible schedule. This can be especially beneficial for patients who require frequent monitoring or assistance with medication throughout the day and night.

One potential disadvantage of hiring a home nurse is that they may be more expensive than traditional caregivers. However, this cost can be offset by their specialized medical care and the ability to reduce hospital stays and readmissions.

Maids/Domestic Helpers

Maids and domestic helpers assist with household chores and daily tasks, such as cooking, cleaning, and laundry. They may also provide companionship and assistance with personal care, such as bathing and dressing.

One advantage of hiring a maid or domestic helper is that they can assist with a wide range of tasks, from cooking meals to running errands. This can reduce the workload on family members and provide additional support for those who need it.

Another advantage of hiring a maid or domestic helper is that they may be less expensive than traditional caregivers or home nurses. This can be particularly beneficial for those who do not require specialized medical care.

One potential disadvantage of hiring a maid or domestic helper is that they may have a different level of training than a licensed caregiver or nurse. This can be a concern for those who require specialized medical care or have complex medical needs.

Final Thoughts

The terms caregiver and caretaker are often confused as the same, but they are not. However, it doesn’t necessarily mean that the terms have opposite meanings. Most of their tasks overlap, and they are also both required to know how to give and find support for the patients they are looking after.

Both jobs provide challenges, and these people feel exhausted too. If you have employed a caregiver or caretaker for a family member, make sure that they are aware of their specific roles and updated about the NCSS advisory on caregiver support.

RC Caregivers can provide more information about the caregiver vs caretaker argument, and we can also help you find the right person, including maids or home nurses, depending on your requirements. Click here to learn more about the differences between a caregiver and a domestic maid.

Joshua is the founder of RC Caregivers. Having been the primary caregiver of his father, he has been undertaking ways to provide affordable and quality care, not just to his father, but to all elderly in Singapore. He has founded multiple care companies, such as Red Crowns Senior Living, and has been featured in Straits Times, Zaobao and Money 93FM. He has also been lauded by DBS, with the company being the recipient of the DBS foundation grant.
Cta Section

Start Getting The Best Care

Hiring a caregiver might not only be a necessity
but a gift you can give yourself. Get started with a free care assessment and learn more about Red Crowns Caregivers.