BlogMaids & Caregivers

Caregiver vs Home Nurse: Which Should You Choose?

Pexels Kampus Production 7551607

As people get older, they will require more care and attention. No matter how much you love the elderly members of your family, you will need able and helping hands once you can no longer commit to all the tasks involved in looking after them on your own.

This is especially true for family members who have jobs, businesses, or own families. Handling medical care, daily living, personal hygiene, wound care, medical assistance, or medication administration all at once may be too much for people who lack training. They may appear unimaginable to those with other things to do daily besides ensuring the well-being of the senior citizens at home.

In Singapore, you have several options for the eldercare of a family member. Two of the most common among these options are home nurses and caregivers.

Let us look at the differences between the two and weigh the pros and cons of each choice. This way, it will be easier for you to choose which option will provide care, assistance, and personal care to your senior family members.

Professional Caregiver – The Definition

Professional caregivers have received training to provide home care services and assist seniors in their ADLs or activities of daily living. Seniors who can no longer perform most activities of daily living on their own, such as using the toilet, walking, transferring, taking a bath, dressing, and eating, require assistance around the clock.

Home caregivers also fill your loved one’s need for social activities or engagement and emotional support. They provide companionship, and all the care seniors need for their health, life, and daily activities.

A home caregiver has undergone training to make the life of their care recipient easier to live. A home caregiver can be tasked with light housekeeping, meal preparation, and offering basic help to another family member.

A home caregiver can also do medical care, wound care, medication reminders, get vital signs, use feeding tubes, and other basic home health requirements. However, they cannot perform tasks they were not licensed to do, such as administering medication, taking blood samples, and IV therapy.

A caregiver gives home care services while making older adults feel cared for. A caregiver lets you focus on your work, knowing that your elderly loved ones are in good and able hands.

The cost of hiring caregivers depends on the requirement of the patient and if you want to pay them at an hourly or daily rate.

At-Home Nurse – The Definition

Unlike caregivers, an at-home nurse is a licensed expert and trained to perform the duties of a private nurse. They can do nursing care procedures and medical tasks on a patient.

A home nurse has a bachelor’s degree in nursing and can provide skilled medical care as a licensed practical nurse. You may want to consider hiring a registered nurse when the elderly people at your home require many medical services that primary caregivers can’t perform.

An at-home nurse can provide the patient with their nursing needs at home round the clock. This means you can have their overall wellness checked all the time without moving your elderly loved one far from familiar surroundings.

A nurse can render specialist medical care and other nursing services to provide comfort and improve the quality of life of a patient.

Similar to caregivers, you can hire home nurses at an hourly rate. You can also arrange for two nurses to show up on a shifting schedule so your loved one has someone to tend to their needs 24/7.

All About the Cost of Hiring a Caregiver and Home Nurse

Like in any service, the cost of hiring a home nurse or caregiver depends on the duration and the care services you will require.

Singapore’s home nursing care services cost around $40 per hour or less. You can offset the cost by applying for subsidies and availing of care packages.

If you badly need the service, but the cost doesn’t fit your budget, you can defray home care by applying for financial subsidies at Home Caregiving Grant.

Generally, the cost of getting a caregiver is slightly lower than the rate of a registered nurse.

What Are the Best Home Care Services Your Loved Ones Need?

You don’t have to place your elderly loved ones in nursing homes if you find the thought unimaginable. There’s nothing wrong with it, and nursing homes are equipped with the right staff and tools.

However, many children can’t bear living away from their parents, especially when they are at the point in their lives when they are constantly looking for familiar faces and a home environment.

The services you will require from either a caregiver or a home nurse will affect the cost of their salary. You can also request other home medical services, depending on the needs of your loved one.

Here’s a look at the home care services you can request for your loved one and how much their hourly cost would be:


You can now schedule an appointment for a teleconsultation so your loved ones won’t need to travel back and forth to a clinic or hospital. You can also request for medicine delivery service.

This arrangement typically costs about $20 per consultation or prescription.

House-call doctors

Despite having a caregiver or home nurse, there are times when you would need a doctor for your loved ones. Now it’s possible to arrange a doctor’s visit to your home.

The doctor can perform health screenings and medical consultations. They can also provide medical certifications and provide specialist referrals.

The cost can be around $60 for every surgical or medical procedure done and $180 per hour for basic consultations.

Home therapy

It is also now possible to request rehabilitation therapy for your loved one at home. Here are some of the services you can avail of, which cost around $180 per hour:

  • Occupational therapy. Occupational therapists can help patients boost their mobility and easily do basic daily tasks.
  • Speech therapy. Speech therapists use exercises to help the patient regain functions, such as swallowing, voice, and speech.
  • Physiotherapy. It helps patients gain muscle and joint strength and restore their motor skills after surgery, illness, or injury.

The Judgement – A Caregiver or a Home Nurse?

The choice is not yours to make; you have to get a professional to address your family member’s needs. You may settle with a caregiver if the patient has difficulties performing daily activities but doesn’t require whole-day health monitoring.

However, if your loved one needs medical care services often during the day, it is best to hire a home nurse.

RC Caregivers can shed light on the home care services suited to your needs. We will guide you through the process of choosing and walk you through the financial aid you can apply for. We’re here to assist both the patient and those who care for their welfare.

Recent Articles:

Cta Section

Start Getting The Best Care

Hiring a caregiver might not only be a necessity
but a gift you can give yourself. Get started with a free care assessment and learn more about Red Crowns Caregivers.